The most widely agreed finding in digital transformation is this: success is determined not by technology but by leadership. This finding now rests on broad data and is not disputed in the industry.
When you look at maturity assessments, however, a different picture emerges. Most of the models in use have no leadership dimension. What is measured is systems, infrastructure and processes; the layer said to determine success is left out of the report.
This article examines that contradiction with data. Why is leadership regarded as the most important layer while being the least measured one? And is measuring it really possible?
The Truth Everyone Knows: Leadership Determines Success
In McKinsey’s 2018 global survey, only 16% of digital transformations had both improved performance and been able to sustain the gains. The same research groups the characteristics of success into five categories: leadership, building capabilities, empowering workers, upgrading tools, communication. Four out of five are about people; only one is about technology. (Survey finding.)
In Prosci’s benchmarking research, running since 1998, the number one factor in change success has been the same in every period: active and visible sponsorship. It is cited four times more often than the other factors. The same research’s second finding is talked about less: 58% of sponsors do not fully understand their own role. The consequence has been measured too: in projects with very ineffective sponsors, the likelihood of meeting objectives is 27%; in those with very effective ones, 79%.
BCG’s 10-20-70 resource allocation points in the same direction: 10% of transformation effort goes to algorithms, 20% to technology and data, 70% to people and processes. This is a principle, not a measurement — and it should be reported as such.
The Uncomfortable Part: The Least Measured Layer
A systematic review published in 2024 (van Tonder et al., Journal of Technology Management & Innovation) counted, dimension by dimension, 23 digital maturity models used for SMEs. The result: strategy is measured in 15 of the 23 models, people/employees in 13, organisation in 11, technology in 9. Leadership in only 7 — third from last among nine dimensions. (Content analysis.)
| Dimension | Number of the 23 models that measure it |
|---|---|
| Strategy | 15 |
| People / employees | 13 |
| Organisation | 11 |
| Technology | 9 |
| Culture | 8 |
| Customer | 8 |
| Leadership | 7 |
| Process | 6 |
| Product | 6 |
The table does not say "the industry ignores people". The "employee" dimension is measured even more often than technology. What is ignored is the management layer of people. The same review reports one more detail: some researchers count strategy and leadership as a single dimension. In other words, even where leadership does appear, it dissolves into strategy and is left without a score of its own.
In industry-specific models, the picture gets harsher. In a review that examined general and industry-specific models separately (Teichert, 2019), the area most addressed by industry-specific models, manufacturing among them, is technology. Leadership is at the very bottom — appearing only once on the list. The same study also has a counter-finding: in general models, the most addressed area is digital culture. The problem is not in every model; it deepens the further you go into specific industries.
Another review published this year (Stef et al., 2026) screened 60 studies. Most of the models look at operational, organisational and strategic elements together. The number of models that make strategy an assessment axis in its own right, however, is only three across the 60 studies. The debate about criteria in the fourth article in the series finds its counterpart precisely here.
The layer we agree is the most important is the layer we measure least. It is not that leadership is not measured — it is not measured in its own right.
Why Is It Not Measured? Three Honest Reasons
1. It Is Hard
The number of servers, the number of modules, the data infrastructure can be counted. They can be audited, invoiced and put into a table. Leadership relies on self-assessment, is open to perception and is sensitive. Measuring what is easy to measure has always been more tempting.
2. It Is Uncomfortable
If the technology score comes out low, that is a justification for investment; nobody takes offence. If the leadership score comes out low, it points at the person who commissioned the report. A report that says "the real gap is you" is hard to sell.
3. The "It Cannot Be Measured" Excuse
The weakest of the three reasons, because it is not true. The MLQ, used to measure transformational leadership, has been tested in thousands of academic studies. There are scales developed for digital leadership whose validity has been tested; one of them has been adapted into Turkish and validated on a sample in Türkiye.
A note: measuring leadership is not an objective reading in the way that measuring technology is. It relies on perception and should be declared as such. But the principle mentioned in the fourth article in the series applies here too: the problem is not the flaw but the undeclared flaw. A measurement that openly states it is perception-based, involves many participants and has a published method is better than not measuring at all.
An X-Ray Shows the Skeleton, Not the Heart
An X-ray shows bone perfectly. If you need to see the heart, an X-ray is not enough; another kind of imaging is needed. There is nothing wrong with the machine — the wrong organ is being imaged with that machine.
Most of today’s maturity reports take an X-ray of the skeleton of transformation: systems, infrastructure, processes. The skeleton matters. But the heart attack that kills the transformation does not show up on that film.
5 Questions That Probe the Leadership Layer
Five questions to ask in your next maturity assessment, or within your organisation today, quickly show whether the leadership layer is being measured:
- Who owns this transformation? If the answer is "IT" or "the project team", the most critical factor has been delegated from the outset.
- Can top management describe what the sponsorship role requires? Signing off is not sponsorship; sponsorship is being visible, defending resources and stepping forward when there is resistance.
- What does middle management gain from this transformation? The "frozen middle", which says yes in the meeting and changes nothing on the ground, is the silent killer of most transformations.
- When did the leadership team last assess its own digital competence? A management that does not itself do the learning it asks of its team is managing the transformation with words.
- Does the maturity report you received have a leadership dimension — and how was it measured? If not, the film in your hands shows the skeleton; not the heart.
Conclusion
The gap in maturity measurement is not a technical constraint. Measurement tools exist, their validity has been tested, and there is even one adapted into Turkish. The only thing missing is the integration of these tools into maturity assessments — and the willingness to show in the report a score that may come out low.
The next article in the series will look one step beyond this: why is it so rare to open up the kitchen of a measurement tool — its method, its assumptions, its limits — to the public?
This article is the fifth instalment in the growing «From Man-Days to Value»
series.
1. Is Consulting That
Sells Man-Days Coming to an End?
2. Let’s X-Ray the Promises
of AI
3. What Has AI Made
Cheaper in ERP, and What Has It Made Valuable?
4. Diagnosis First: What Does the New Path
in ERP Look Like in Practice?
5. The Unmeasured Layer of Digital Transformation: Leadership (this article)
6. Why Do Reports
Stay on the Shelf in Digital Transformation?
7. (coming soon)
To make sure you do not miss new analyses, subscribe to the MindDX-Digital Excellence newsletter.
