What are ESG reporting and the carbon footprint?
ESG stands for environmental, social and governance. ESG reporting is the measurement of risk, opportunity and performance under these headings against a given framework, and their disclosure to investors, customers and the public.
The carbon footprint is the most frequently asked-about part of the environmental dimension: the total of the greenhouse gas emissions caused by a company or a product, expressed as carbon dioxide equivalent. The corporate carbon footprint looks at the whole company, the product carbon footprint at the life cycle of a single product.
Which framework binds a company?
A company in Türkiye may face several frameworks at once. Which one binds you depends on the size of the company, its export markets, its sector and the demands of its customers. The table below gives a first screening; the definitive assessment is made against the text of the regulation concerned.
| Framework | Who it concerns | What it requires |
|---|---|---|
| TSRS | Companies within the scope set by decisions of the Public Oversight Authority | Disclosure of sustainability-related and climate-related information |
| EU CBAM | Manufacturers exporting products to the EU in the sectors covered | Embedded emissions data per product; input to the declaration of the importer in the EU |
| Turkish emissions trading system | Installations within the scope of the Climate Law | Monitoring and reporting of installation emissions |
| Customer and supply chain demands | Companies supplying large customers | Questionnaires, product carbon data and reduction targets |
| GRI | Companies reporting voluntarily | Disclosure of the company’s impacts on the economy, the environment and people |
What is TSRS, and who must apply it?
The Turkish Sustainability Reporting Standards (TSRS) are standards published by the Public Oversight, Accounting and Auditing Standards Authority (KGK) and aligned with the international sustainability disclosure standards. One sets out the general requirements for sustainability-related information, the other the climate-related disclosures.
The scope of application is set by KGK decisions and published in the Official Gazette: together with entities of certain types, companies that exceed two of the criteria of total assets, net sales revenue and number of employees in two consecutive reporting periods fall within scope. Because the thresholds and the transitional exemptions are updated over time, assess your company’s position against the current decision texts listed in the sources section.
What does CBAM mean for an exporting manufacturer?
The EU Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM, known in Türkiye by its Turkish acronym SKDM) puts a price on the emissions released in the production of goods imported into the EU, such as cement, iron and steel, aluminium, fertilisers, electricity and hydrogen. The obligation lies with the importer in the EU; however, the importer asks the manufacturer for the embedded emissions data it needs for its declaration.
According to the Ministry of Trade of Türkiye, the transitional period focused on reporting has ended and the period of financial obligation has begun. Where actual emissions data cannot be provided, default values may be used; however, these often do not reflect the manufacturer’s actual performance. Producing accurate data per product requires a traceable link between production orders, recipes and energy consumption.
What are Scope 1, Scope 2 and Scope 3 emissions?
The Greenhouse Gas Protocol divides emissions into three scopes. The distinction determines which emissions are under the company’s direct control and where the data is to be collected from.
| Scope | What it includes | Typical data source |
|---|---|---|
| Scope 1 | Direct emissions from sources the company owns or controls | Natural gas and fuel invoices, the vehicle fleet, refrigerant gas maintenance records |
| Scope 2 | Indirect emissions from purchased electricity, steam, heat and cooling | Electricity invoices, meters and energy monitoring data |
| Scope 3 | Other indirect emissions in the value chain | Purchasing and supplier data in ERP, logistics, the use of products and end of life |
Where does emissions data come from inside the company?
The hardest part of a carbon footprint calculation is not the formula but the data. The good news is that most of the data already exists in the company; the problem is that it is scattered. Invoices sit in accounting, meter data in maintenance or facilities, purchasing in ERP and, at a manufacturer, production consumption on the shop floor.
For a manufacturer, emissions per product, especially for CBAM, require these data to be combined at production order level. The recipes and production orders in ERP and the energy and consumption data collected by MES and IIoT establish this link.
- Invoices and metersFuel, natural gas and electricity consumption.
- ERPPurchasing, suppliers, logistics, recipes and production orders.
- MES and IIoTEnergy and consumption per machine, line and product.
- Emission factorsCurrent coefficients that convert consumption into greenhouse gas equivalent.
- Calculation and reportCorporate and product carbon footprint; disclosure according to the framework.
Collecting shop-floor data: the MES and IIoT guide
Software, verification and assurance are not the same thing
An ESG or carbon software collects the data, applies the factors and calculates. Verification of an emissions report by an independent body, or assurance on sustainability disclosures, are separate, independent steps, carried out by the bodies defined in the regulation concerned.
So the question to ask when choosing software is not «does it produce a report?» but «does it leave an evidence trail a verifier can follow?»: which data, from which source, with which factor and entered by whom?
Spreadsheet or ESG platform?
For a start with a single site and a single reporting framework, a spreadsheet may be enough. A platform comes onto the agenda when these needs appear:
- an auditable evidence trail: seeing the source of every figure and who changed it,
- versioning of emission factors and preserving the base year,
- calculating several sites, companies or product groups with the same method,
- taking data automatically from ERP, MES and energy monitoring systems,
- producing reports for more than one framework from the same data.
The difference between GRI, TSRS and the European standards
Reporting frameworks answer different questions. The table below compares the three frameworks a company in Türkiye meets most often by their focus.
| Framework | Published by | Focus |
|---|---|---|
| GRI | Global Reporting Initiative | The company’s impacts on the economy, the environment and people |
| TSRS | Public Oversight, Accounting and Auditing Standards Authority | The effect of sustainability and climate matters on the company’s financial position |
| European Sustainability Reporting Standards | European Union | Both impacts and financial effect; customers in the EU may ask their suppliers for data |
Where does reporting start?
A sound start is made by clarifying which framework really binds you. The following steps then follow: an inventory of emission sources and data owners, the choice of a base year, the first calculation, closing the data gaps, preparing for verification or assurance and setting up the annual reporting cycle.
MindDX starts this path with Assess: which framework applies, where the data sits in the company and how ERP and operational data, including shop-floor data where there is production, will be connected to this calculation are established with evidence; the choice of tool comes after this scope.
The role of MindDX
At MindDX, ESG is a solution area; it is not tied to a particular product. The contribution of MindDX is to connect sustainability data to operational data: turning purchasing and supplier data in ERP and, in manufacturing, recipes, production orders and the consumption data collected by MES and IIoT into traceable input for the emissions calculation. The calculation or reporting tool is chosen according to the validated scope.